Narendra Modi’s Populist Facade Is Cracking
India is now a testing ground for whether demagoguery or deteriorating living conditions exert a greater sway on voters.

## The Modi Era: A Test of Populism in India### Rise of a StrongmanOn a frigid winter afternoon in 2024, Prime Minister Narendra Modi ascended the podium before a handpicked audience of India's elite. Modi's rhetoric, brimming with confidence and national pride, resonated with his supporters. He vowed to transform India into an economic powerhouse, a maritime giant, and a beacon of human potential. With each fiery word, the mood in Ayodhya, Uttar Pradesh, where Modi dedicated a newly built Hindu temple, soared.### A Promise UnfulfilledAs Modi's tenure progressed, skepticism began to creep in among his once-adoring electorate. Economic growth, heavily skewed towards the wealthy, did not trickle down to the masses. The construction boom and infrastructure projects overshadowed neglected sectors such as education and healthcare. Despite lofty promises, schools remained in a state of disrepair, and hospitals were ill-equipped.### The Roots of DisillusionmentLuv Shukla, a small-town shop owner, witnessed the growing discontent firsthand. He had initially supported Modi's Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), but in 2024, he voted against the ruling party, helping trigger a shift in Indian politics. Among the reasons he cited was the BJP's obsession with protecting cows, which had become a source of harassment for farmers.### Economic Woes and Political BlundersModi's economic policies, such as the 2016 currency demonetization, had disastrous consequences. The mishandling of the COVID-19 pandemic left the country reeling from staggering losses. Modi's efforts to suppress dissent and manipulate the justice system further eroded public trust.### Hindutva's ShadowsThe core of Modi's ideology, Hindutva, aimed to promote Hindu nationalist ideals. While it resonated with some, it also fueled religious tensions and marginalized minority communities, especially Muslims. The election results hinted at a growing dissatisfaction with Modi's communal rhetoric and his failure to address pressing economic and social challenges.### India's Test GroundIndia has become a proving ground for the long-term effects of populist leadership. Modi's tenure has raised fundamental questions: does the allure of demagoguery outweigh the realities of declining living standards? Will the country's democratic institutions withstand the pressures of polarization and political maneuvering?### From Tea Vendor to Temple ArchitectThe roots of Modi's rise to power can be traced back to his humble beginnings as a tea seller from a lower caste. His ascent through the ranks of the RSS, a Hindu nationalist organization, shaped his worldview. Modi's role in the 2002 Gujarat riots, in which hundreds of Muslims were killed, stained his reputation but also cemented his image as a strong defender of Hindutva.### The National Volunteer AssociationThe RSS, founded in 1925, aimed to revive Hindu identity and strength in response to perceived threats from other religions and colonizers. It promoted a disciplined approach and a uniform dress code for its members. Its affiliated groups, including the BJP, sought to spread Hindutva and establish it as the glue holding India together.### Ayodhya: A Symbol of DivisionIn 1992, a mob led by Hindu zealots destroyed the Babri Masjid, a centuries-old mosque, in the holy city of Ayodhya. The destruction ignited religious tensions and led to large-scale violence. Modi, then a party worker for the RSS, was present on the fateful day. Years later, he returned to the same spot to oversee the construction of a Hindu temple on the site. This act further deepened the divide between Hindus and Muslims.### Nehru's Modern India and Its DemiseIndia's first Prime Minister, Jawaharlal Nehru, envisioned a secular and inclusive nation. His legacy was gradually eroded, as religious chauvinism and economic inequality took hold. Caste divisions, persistent poverty, and a widening gap between the rich and the poor further strained the social fabric.### Rise of a New EliteModi's election in 2014 coincided with a surge in economic growth and the emergence of a new capitalist class. Global forces, such as the rise of China, also influenced India's political and economic trajectory. India faced increasing pressure to take sides in the global power struggle.### India's Global AmbitionsModi actively pursued a more prominent role for India on the world stage. He cultivated close ties with the United States and other Western powers while aligning with Russia on certain issues. However, India's efforts to flex its geopolitical muscle were sometimes met with embarrassment, such as the assassination plot against a Sikh leader in Canada, allegedly orchestrated by Indian officials.### India's Wealthy Elite vs. the Neglected MajorityEconomic growth under Modi's leadership disproportionately benefited the upper classes, while the majority of Indians continued to struggle with basic needs. Unemployment, poverty, and inadequate healthcare cast a shadow over the supposed economic boom. The contrast became even more stark in rural areas, where millions of people were forced to migrate to cities in search of better opportunities.### Failures in Education and the Future of IndiaThe state of education in India has become a pressing concern. Low-quality teachers, a lack of resources, and systemic corruption have resulted in abysmal literacy and numeracy rates, especially in rural areas. The exclusion of critical thinking skills and scientific inquiry has crippled the nation's ability to produce innovators and thinkers.### Corruption RampantThe education system is just one example of the widespread corruption that plagued India during Modi's tenure. From traffic police taking bribes to the highest levels of government, corruption has become ingrained in daily life. It has stifled economic growth, eroded public trust, and created an atmosphere of hopelessness.### Freedom of Speech Under FireIndia's declining press freedom has also raised concerns under Modi's rule. Journalists critical of the government have been threatened, harassed, and even jailed. Social media giants, heavily influenced by the government, have suppressed dissenting voices.### A Nation at a CrossroadsThe rise of Modi and the subsequent discontent among the Indian electorate have placed the country at a critical juncture. The outcome of future elections will determine whether India can navigate the challenges posed by populism, inequality, and communalism.### The Shape of Things to ComeIndia's long-term trajectory remains uncertain. The country has the potential to become a prosperous and inclusive democracy, but the forces that divide it run deep. The choice between demagoguery and substance will continue to shape India's future for generations to come.